You decide that as an involved party you should get a cut from it, and go on to make sure that the bet is won. It turned out that Molly had lied and in fact rejected any attempt by the Pinkertons to recruit her, she lied about being a rat to simply get Dutch's attention. Regardless of the player's choices, Arthur and Micah will have one last fight, either a knife fight or a fistfight. Favorite Arthur/John/Mary-Beth headcanons? Arthur and Mary-Beth share a sweet moment round the campfire at Shady Belle as they reminisce over Kieran's unexpected and brutal death. To cope, he goes to live on a Big Valley cattle ranch owned by Jackson and Victoria Linton, two of Mary Linton's descendants. In the original story, none of the characters with the exception of Bill and Pearson had served in the army or any of the forces, but of course, things are drastically different in this. But after their return from Guarma Javier starts to lose respect for Arthur because he has lost faith in Dutch, this is highlighted when Arthur tries to talk Javier about Dutch's erratic behaviour only for him to brush it off and refuse to talk, stating he has nothing to say to him whilst simultaneously questioning Arthur's loyalty. Mary-Beth, he rumbles in reply, the depth of his voice thick with liquor and the cigarette hes nursing. The loss of his son and Eliza made Arthur appreciate the family he had in the Van der Linde gang and perhaps fuelled the frustration he had with John when he ran away after getting Abigail pregnant with Jack. Before Arthur's illness, Micah rarely tried to annoy Arthur and often tried to be friendly with Arthur, respecting him and likely wishing that they could be friends. Arthur spoke up again. After being caught and reprimanded for her actions, she cant help but ask who the woman was. He shows sympathy towards Charles' anger at the mistreatment of the Bisons, knowing that Natives are incredibly reliant on them to survive. She would compliment Arthur's contribution to the camp and at one point said everyone misses him if the player keeps Arthur away from camp long enough. He tries to give Jack advice and, at the request of Abigail, asked if he wanted to go fishing with him. A small rivalry between John and Arthur ensues. They both take each others hands and Abigail says she has always been a good thief to which Arthur acknowledges, giving one final, emotional, goodbye before departing. She is the first to see Kieran's mutilated body, causing her to scream out in horror. While we've done our best to make the core functionality of this site accessible without javascript, it will work better with it enabled. They first work together when trying to infiltrate Leviticus Cornwall's oil factory where Arthur is tasked with finding evidence of the company's intent on removing the Wapiti Tribe from their land to drill for oil. Why? Tilly stares over at her like shes grown a second head. Because Kieran saved Arthur he was granted camp freedom and had the job of caring for the horses. Karen is very sympathetic and encourages Arthur that he can, and should, do better. I used to write a lot for Supernatural (the TV show). Edit: Shout out for my first Silver ever. When the Braithwaites abducted Jack and gave him to Angelo Bronte Arthur was just as worried as Abigail and John and went out of his way to get him back. Arthur's dislike of Micah grew when he inadvertently led him, Bill and Sean into a trap that led to Sean's death and took advantage of Hosea's death to get close to Dutch and have a greater influence on him. Jack just wants a little time with his uncle Arthur, but the man's been very distant lately. On the way back to camp they were bushwhacked by the Lemoyne Raiders. After Arthur died, Charles found his body and buried him on a hillside facing the evening sun, fulfilling Arthur's wish when he was asked how he wanted to be buried by Hosea, Lenny and Tilly. When Kieran invites Arthur on a fishing trip he opens up about his past and reveals that his parents died from cholera when he was young and ended up joining the O'Driscoll Boys, albeit reluctantly. Is the horse the only thing hes bringing back? For most of1899, their relationship is strong and healthy, with Arthur having Dutchs full trust and respect and vice versa. 73 Stories. Arthur has the choice to either let him live or kill him. Karen is also one of the few women that carries out guard duties, which Arthur respects her for. Arthur couldn't help but scornfully question why he couldn't have shown up earlier. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Arthur Morgan is a conflicted, fascinating outlaw who experiences many highs and lows as RDR2's protagonist.When exploring the Van der Linde gang's campsites throughout the story, Arthur can sit down with various gang members to have one-on-one, therapy session-like conversations . However, Arthur would reassure Lenny that he has friends and that he should not try to impress everyone in the gang because the people that matter (himself, Dutch and Hosea) are aware of the effort he puts in. There are other times in the story when Arthur and John bicker, for example, when John gets Arthur's help to steal some sheep to sell off in Valentine the two can be heard arguing about Jack, with John complaining that Arthur took him fishing and with Arthur responding that John should be spending more time with his family, especially Jack. After helping Archibald MacGregor destroy a distillery in the Bayou, Dutch asked Arthur if he wanted to race back to camp. Arthur would regularly bring Charles on jobs, believing him to be a more reliable pair of hands than anybody else in the gang. At camp Karen may sometimes go up to Arthur to talk to him, particularly when she is drunk. Their relationship is actually one of the best plot lines in RDR2. I can guess. Karen smirks, glances to the other side of camp where their horses are tethered. Boy has all the dexterity of his father before him, but he still managed a better job than Uncle who was on the bottle before I could get him working. AU, Alternate Ending. However, John is one of the gang members Arthur can play Poker with. Your trusted horse, however, wasnt so lucky. This is the last time they see each other, with Trelawny admitting that he will miss Arthur and tells him that he has been a fine friend to him. Arthur, with Miss Grimshaw, rescue Tilly and successfully capture Anthony Foreman, who Tilly warns to stay away from her. "Mary's a bad person for not wanting to join Arthur and his gang of ruthless murderers and criminals. Arthur, along with Dutch and Micah, rescued Sadie early on in the story when the O'Driscoll Boys ransacked her home and killed her husband. On the boat he acts as Arthur's friend and tells him to go play Poker with Desmond Blythe, as part of the plan. After getting the dynamite for an upcoming heist Arthur tells John that whatever happens during the robbery, and wherever Dutch goes, he will get him the money he needs and get out of this life. The relationship Arthur has with other characters can be dictated by the actions of the player, for example, the player is given the choice to talk to various gang members whilst at camp in either a positive manner or a negative one. Abigail is saddened when Arthur is forced to part ways with her and Sadie because he has to confront Micah. If you look at Arthurs interaction with people who dont speak English It seems like he has little to no patience with them lmfao. A/N: This was probably the easiest request for me to do because I go to sleep imagining this everyday. Charles mentions to Arthur that Javier has changed to which Arthur calls him a "little sack of shit"he shouldve lethim to die in Guarma, signifying that their once close friendship has ended. Hamish is perhaps the only person in the game Arthur builds an authentic and genuine friendship with, Arthur never mocks Hamish and enjoys his company in spite of Arthur's reclusiveness trait. Thought you might find it useful, hed say, giving you a brand new journal. Hosea adds on that they were "a curious couple with their unruly child." Shes smiling, a bright open grin that lights up the room as she accepts a beer from a blushing waiter that John is immediately and overwhelmingly jealous of. In a canon-compliant universe up until the Pinkerton ambush on Lakay, Mary Beth and Arthur start their new life together, trying not to worry about what tomorrow will bring and living for today. Hosea often calls for Arthur's backing when he is having disputes with Dutch, and even with some fellow gang members such as Bill. She is ultimately killed by Micah when she is caught off guard by Javier shouting that Pinkertons are on their way. This is what actually started me writing RDR2 fic. Arthur would help Sean when robbing a small cabin and when they set fire to the Gray Family's fields. She is the first to find and help Arthur after he escapes from Colm O'Driscoll and his men where he was tortured. At the camp Bill can ask Arthur for some hair pomade and in return will leave Arthur repeater ammo beside his tent. Arthur mentions Isaac when conversing with Rains Fall, telling him that the incident made him realize that he can't expect good things to happen to him with the life he led. If Arthur does this there will be a regular supply of fire and poison arrows beside his bed. Helping the Wapiti Tribe and Eagle Flies gave Arthur the chance to redeem himself by doing the right thing, however, the needless death of a young man due to Dutch's manipulation and refusal to help Arthur causes him to solidify his opposition to Dutch. As the events of 1899 unfold, Dutch seems to view Arthur as something of an ace in the hole and relies on him more and more to get the gang out of increasingly difficult situations. Initially, Arthur viewed Rains Fall as weak because of his pacifism, a stark contrast to Arthur's lifestyle. He decides to leave the gang and, should Arthur not help the nun in Saint Denis, will meet Swanson at the train station after dropping off Captain Monroe. Lenny's performance and competency impressed Arthur to such an extent that he declares he will ride with Lenny anytime. Whilst at camp Javier can ask Arthur to find him some Oleander, and in return he will regularly leave throwing knives at his tent. When Dutch intervenes in the fight he tells him of his success with John, ultimately feeling a sense of redemption because of this and no longer caring if he dies. After many years. Hosea can occasionally come up to Arthur and talk to him around camp. She can mention to him that she used to play the Harmonica but no longer has one, which allows Arthur to find one for her. They find two of Cornwall's men and go to stealth kill them, only for Uncle to fumble it and Arthur is then forced to save him. If you've never been a relationship where you both love one another but just can't make it work because you aren't quite compatible then you won't really get it. It hits all the feelings you get from it. Arthur goes to check on the cabin only to be surprised and held at gun point, however, Kieran saves his life by shooting the O'Driscoll first. He does, however, keep a photographof her beside his bed, and often speaks fondly of her, in contrast to his father. Please consider turning it on! Arthur admired and respected Hamish greatly because of the way he has lived his life, despite his prosthetic leg. She took time to adjust to her new life with the Van der Linde gang and would mostly be with Abigail. Please consider turning it on! If the player has high honor, Micah will instead leave Arthur to die. At Valentine, when John and Strauss got themselves captured by Leviticus Cornwall's men, Arthur tells Dutch to confront and talk to them whilst he waits for him to make a move, an idea that Dutch agreed to without hesitation. Likelihood is that it'll all be happy ending stuff because I'm a happy ending sorta gal, not a sad, angsty sorta one. The player can have Arthur partake in various activities throughout the story, as an outlaw both within the Van der Linde gang and outside of it, that will define his relationship with certain characters. Summary: It reaches your ears that there in camp goes on a bet that you and Arthur will end up together. Arthur comforts him and tells him that he no longer has to worry about being alone again. Sadie is quiet around camp but will occasionally come up to Arthur to have a chat.